Spatial Sound Rendering – A Survey
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.9781/ijimai.2018.06.001Keywords:
Virtual Reality, Immersion, Real-time Spatial Audio, Acoustics, 3D Sound, Auralization, Simulation of Sound Propagation, Real-time SystemsAbstract
Simulating propagation of sound and audio rendering can improve the sense of realism and the immersion both in complex acoustic environments and dynamic virtual scenes. In studies of sound auralization, the focus has always been on room acoustics modeling, but most of the same methods are also applicable in the construction of virtual environments such as those developed to facilitate computer gaming, cognitive research, and simulated training scenarios. This paper is a review of state-of-the-art techniques that are based on acoustic principles that apply not only to real rooms but also in 3D virtual environments. The paper also highlights the need to expand the field of immersive sound in a web based browsing environment, because, despite the interest and many benefits, few developments seem to have taken place within this context. Moreover, the paper includes a list of the most effective algorithms used for modelling spatial sound propagation and reports their advantages and disadvantages. Finally, the paper emphasizes in the evaluation of these proposed works.Downloads
References
M. Naef, O. Staadt and M. Gross, “Spatialized audio rendering for immersive virtual environments”, VRST ‘02 Proceedings of the ACM symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology, pp. 65-72, 2002.
M. Pallot, P. Daras, S. Richir and E. Loup-Escande, “3D-live: live interactions through 3D visual environments”, Proceedings of the 2012 Virtual Reality International Conference, article No. 23, pp 8 2012.
F. Hamid and B. Kapralos, “A Review of Spatial Sound for Virtual Environments and Games with Graphics Processing Units”, The Open Virtual Reality Journal, Volume 1, pp. 8-17, 2009.
H. Yeh, R. Mehra, Z. Ren, L. Antani, D. Manocha and M. Lin, “Wave-ray coupling for interactive sound propagation in large complex scenes”, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG) - Proceedings of ACM SIGGRAPH Asia 2013 TOG Homepage archive, Volume 32, pp. 165, Issue 6, 2013.
C. Lauterbach, A. Chandak and D. Manocha, “Interactive sound rendering in complex and dynamic scenes using frustum tracing”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume. 13, Issue 6, pp. 1672 – 1679, 2007.
A. Sterling and M. C. Lin, “Interactive modal sound synthesis using generalized proportional damping”, I3D ‘16 Proceedings of the 20th ACM SIGGRAPH Symposium on Interactive 3D Graphics and Games, pp. 79- 86, 2016.
M. Labschütz, “Realistic real-time audio rendering in virtual environments”, cg.tuwien.ac.at, 2011.
M. Vorländer, “Auralization: Fundamentals of Acoustics”, Modelling, Simulation, Algorithms, and Acoustic Virtual Reality, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 335, ISBN: 978-3-540-48829-3, 2008.
T. Funkhouser, N. Tsingos, and J. M. Jot, “Survey of Methods for Modeling Sound Propagation in Interactive Virtual Environment Systems”, Citeseer, 2003.
C. Schissler, R. Mehra and D. Manocha, “High-order diffraction and diffuse reflections for interactive sound propagation in large environments”, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG) - Proceedings of ACM SIGGRAPH, Volume 33, pp 12, Issue 4, 2014.
R. Mehra and D. Manocha, “Wave-based sound propagation for VR applications”, VR Workshop: Sonic Interaction in Virtual Environments (SIVE), pp 41-46, 2014.
N.Atalla and R.J.Bernhard, “Review of numerical solutions for lowfrequency structural-acoustic problems”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 43, Issue 3, pp 271-294, 1994.
KJ Bathe, “Finite element procedures”. Publisher: Prentice Hall, Pearson Education, Inc., First Edition, ISBN 978-0-9790049-5-7, 1996.
L. Savioja, T. Rinne and T. Takala, “Simulation of room acoustics with a 3D finite difference mesh”, Proceedings of Intl. Computer Music Conf. (ICMC94), pp. 463–466, 1994.
N. Tsingos, C. Dachsbacher, S.Lefebvre and M. Dellepiane, “Instant sound scattering”, EGSR’07 Proceedings of the 18th Eurographics conference on Rendering Techniques, pp. 111-120, 2007.
D. Quinn, “A finite element method for computing sound propagation in ducts containing flow”, 5th Aeroacoustics Conference, https://doi
. org/10.2514/6.1979-661, 1979.
L. L. Thompson, “A review of finite-element methods for time-harmonic acoustics”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume. 119, pp 1315-1330, Issue 3, 2006.
Y.T. Chou and S.Y. Hsia, “Numerical Analysis of Indoor Sound Quality Evaluation Using Finite Element Method”, Mathematical Problems in Engineering, Volume 2013, pp. 8, 2013.
R. Mehra, N. Raghuvanshi, L. Antani, A. Chandak, S. Curtis and D. Manocha, “Wave-based sound propagation in large open scenes using an equivalent source formulation”, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG), Volume 32, pp 13, Issue 2, 2013.
L. Savioja, “Modeling techniques for virtual acoustics”, Ph.D. dissertation, Helsinki University of Technology, Telecommunications Software and Multimedia Laboratory, Helsinki, Finland, 1999.
R. Mehra, R, L. Antani, S. Kim and D. Manocha, “Source and Listener Directivity for Interactive Wave-Based Sound Propagation”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 20, Issue 4, pp. 495 – 503, 2014.
L.H. Chen and D.G. Schweikert, “Sound Radiation from an Arbitrary Body”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 35, pp 1626-1632, Issue 10, 1963.
K. A. Cunefare and G. Koopmann, “A boundary element method for acoustic radiation valid for all wavenumbers”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 85, pp 39, Issue 1, 1989.
J. Zhenlin M. Qiang and Z. Zhihua, “Application of the Boundary Element Method to Predicting Acoustic Performance of Expansion Chamber Mufflers With Mean Flow”, Journal of Sound and Vibration, Volume 173, Issue 1, pp 57-71, 1994.
B. F. G. Katz, “Boundary element method calculation of individual head-related transfer function. I. Rigid model calculation”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 110, pp 2440-2448, Issue 5, 2001.
W. Haijun, L. Yijun and J. Weikang, “A fast multipole boundary element method for 3D multi-domain acoustic scattering problems based on the Burton–Miller formulation”, Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, Volume 36, pp 779-788, Issue 5, 2012.
R. Blumricha and D. Heimann, “A linearized Eulerian sound propagation model for studies of complex meteorological effects”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 112, pp 446, Issue 2, 2002.
E.M. Salomons, R. Blumrich and D. Heimann, “Eulerian time-domain model for sound propagation over a finite-impedance ground surface. Comparison with frequency-domain models”, Acta Acustica united with Acustica, Volume 88, pp 483-492, 2002.
K. Heutschi, M. Horvath and J. Hofmann, “Simulation of Ground Impedance in Finite Difference Time Domain Calculations of Outdoor Sound Propagation”, Acta Acustica united with Acustica, Volume 91, pp 35-40(6), 2005.
V.E. Ostashev, D.K. Wilson, L. Liu, D.F. Aldridge, N.P. Symons and D. Marlin, “Equations for finite-difference, time-domain simulation of sound propagation in moving inhomogeneous media and numerical implementation”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 117, pp 503-517, Issue 2, 2005.
S. Van Duyne and J. O. Smith. “The 2-d digital waveguide mesh”, Applications of Signal Processing to Audio and Acoustics, pp 177–180 (1993).
L. Savioja, T. Lokki and V. Välimäki, “The interpolated 3-D digital waveguide mesh method for room acoustic simulation and auralization”, Conference: Joint Baltic-Nordic Acoustical Meeting, Volume 2, pp 48-52, 2002.
D. T. Murphy, “The digital waveguide mesh: Applications in acoustic modeling and current research directions”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 116, pp 2562-2562 ,Issue 4, 2004.
D. Manocha and M.C. Lin, “Interactive sound rendering”, ComputerAided Design and Computer Graphics, 2009.
C. Schissler and D. Manocha, “Interactive sound propagation and rendering for large multi-source scenes”, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG), Volume 36, pp 4, Issue 1, 2017.
N. Raghuvanshi, J. Snyder, R. Mehra, M. Lin and N. Govindaraju, “Precomputed wave simulation for real-time sound propagation of dynamic sources in complex scenes”, ACM Transactions on Graphics, Volume 29, Issue 4, 2010.
T. Lokki, L. Savioja, R. Vaananen, J. Huopaniemi and T. Takala, “Creating interactive virtual auditory environments”, IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, Volume. 22, pp 49 – 57, Issue 4, 2002.
T. Lokk and L. Savioja, “State-of-the-art in auralization of concet hall models - What is still missing?”, Baltic-Nordic Acoustics Meeting, 2008.
E.; Tavazzi and F. Avanzini, “Distance rendering and perception of nearby virtual sound sources with a near-field filter model”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 115, pp 61–73, 2017.
C. Lauterbach, A. Chandak and D. Manocha, “Interactive sound rendering in complex and dynamic scenes using frustum tracing”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 13, pp 1672-1679, Issue 6, 2007.
L. Savioja, “Real-time 3D finite-difference time-domain simulation of low-and mid-frequency room acoustics”, Proc. of the 13th Int. Conference on Digital Audio Effects (DAFx-10), Graz, Australia, 2010.
N. Raghuvanshi and J. Snyder, “Parametric wave field coding for precomputed sound propagation”, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG) - Proceedings of ACM SIGGRAPH, Volume 33, Issue 4, pp 11, 2014.
T. Funkhouser, I. Carlbom, G. Elko, G. Pingali, M. Sondhi and J.West, “A beam tracing approach to acoustic modeling for interactive virtual environments”, SIGGRAPH ‘98 Proceedings of the 25th annual conference on Computer graphics and interactive techniques, pp 21-32, 1998.
L. Savioja and U.P. Svensson, “Overview of geometrical room acoustic modeling techniques”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 138, pp 708-730, Issue 2, 2015.
S. Lauri, H. Jyri, L. Tapio and V. Ritta, “Creating interactive virtual acoustic environments”, JAES, Volume 47, Issue 9, pp 675-705, 1999.
B.M. Gibbs and D.K. Jones, “A Simple Image Method for Calculating the Distribution of Sound Pressure Levels within an Enclosure”, Acta Acustica united with Acustica, Volume 26, pp 24-32, 1972.
F. Santon, “Numerical prediction of echograms and of the intelligibility of speech in rooms”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 59, pp 1399-1405, Issue 6, 1976.
J. B. Allen and D. A. Berkley, “Image method for efficiently simulating small-room acoustics”, Acoustical Society of America, Volume 65, pp 943-950, Issue 4, 1979.
J. Borish, “Extension of the Image Model to Arbitrary Polyhedra”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 75, pp 1827-1836, 1984.
H. Lee and B-H. Lee, “An efficient algorithm for the image model technique”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 24, pp 87-115, Issue 2, 1988.
M. Vorländer, “Simulation of the transient and steady state sound propagation in rooms using a new combined ray tracing/image source algorithm”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 86, pp 172-178, 1989.
R. Heinz, “Binaural room simulation based on an image source model with addition of statistical methods to include the diffuse sound scattering of walls and to predict the reverberant tail”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 38, Issues 2–4, pp 145-159, 1993.
E.A. Lehmann and A.M. Johansson, “Prediction of energy decay in room impulse responses simulated with an image-source model”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 124, pp 269-277, Issue 1, 2008.
S. G. McGovern, “Fast image method for impulse response calculations of box-shaped rooms”, Applied Acoustics, Volume. 70, Issue 1, pp 182–189, 2009.
O. André, C. Guilherme, D. Paulo, M. D. Thomas, V. José, M. Catarina and S. Jorge, “Real-time dynamic image-source implementation for auralization”, Proceedings of the 16th International Conference on Digital Audio Effects. 16th International Conference on Digital Audio Effects, pp 368-372, 2013.
P. Charalampous and D. Michael, “Tree Traversal Algorithms for Real Time Sound Propagation Calculation”, 55th International Conference: Spatial Audio, pp 4-1, 2014.
P. Svensson, “The Early History of Ray Tracing in Room Acoustics”, Modern Acoustics and Signal Processing, chapter 2, Part of the series Modern Acoustics and Signal Processing, pp 15-31, 2015.
A. Krokstad, S. Strom and S. Sørsdal, “Calculating the acoustical room response by the use of a ray tracing technique”, Journal of Sound and Vibration, Volume 8, pp 118-125, Issue 1, 1968.
A. Kulowski, “Error investigation for the ray tracing technique”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 15, pp 263-274, Issue 4, 1982.
A. Kulowski, “Algorithmic representation of the ray tracing technique”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 18, pp 449-469, Issue 6, 1985.
H. Lehnert, “Systematic errors of the ray-tracing algorithm”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 38, pp 207-221, Issues 2–4, 1993.
D.V. Maercke and J. Martin, “The prediction of echograms and impulse responses within the Epidaure software”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 38, pp 93-114, Issues 2–4, 1993.
K.M. Li, S. Taherzadeh and K. Attenborough, “An improved ray-tracing algorithm for predicting sound propagation outdoors”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 104, pp 2077-2083, Issue 4, 1998.
W. Mueller and F. Ullmann, “A scalable system for 3D audio ray tracing”, Multimedia Computing and Systems – Italy, IEEE, 1999.
A. Alpkocak and K. Sis, “Computing Impulse Response of Room Acoustics Using the Ray-Tracing Method in Time Domain”, Archives of Acoustics, Volume 35, pp 505–519, Issue 4, 2010.
M. Dreher, G. Dutilleux and F. Junker, “Optimized 3D ray tracing algorithm for environmental acoustic studies”, Proceedings of the Acoustics 2012 Nantes Conference, 2012.
M. Okada, T. Onoye and W. Kobayashi, “A Ray Tracing Simulation of Sound Diffraction Based on the Analytic Secondary Source Model”, IEEE Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, Volume 20, pp 2448 – 2460, Issue 9, 2012.
M. Taylor, A. Chandak, Q. Mo, C. Lauterbach, C. Schissler and D. Manocha, “Guided Multiview Ray Tracing for Fast Auralization”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 18, pp 1797 – 1810, Issue 11, 2012.
Q. Mo, H. Yeh and D. Manocha, “Tracing Analytic Ray Curves for Light and Sound Propagation in Non-linear Media”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 22, pp 2493 – 2506, Issue 11, 2016.
Q. Mo, H. Yeh, M. Lin and D. Manocha, “Analytic ray curve tracing for outdoor sound propagation”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 104, pp 142–151, 2016.
C. Schissler and D. Manocha, “Adaptive impulse response modeling for interactive sound propagation”, Proceedings of the 20th ACM SIGGRAPH Symposium on Interactive 3D Graphics and Games, pp 71-78, 2016.
P. Charalampous and D. Michael, “Sound propagation in 3D spaces using computer graphics techniques”, Virtual Systems & Multimedia, 2015.
T. Lewers, “A combined beam tracing and radiant exchange computer model of room acoustics”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 38, pp 161-178, Issues 2–4, 1993.
T. Funkhouser, P. Min and I. Carlbom, “Real-time acoustic modeling for distributed virtual environments”, Proceedings of the 26th annual conference on Computer graphics and interactive techniques, pp 365-374, 1999.
T. Funkhouser, I. Carlbom, G. Elko, G. Pingali, M. Sondhi and J. West, “Interactive Acoustic Modeling of Complex Environments”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 105, pp 1357-1358 , Issue 2, 1999.
N. Tsingos, T. Funkhouser, A. Ngan and I. Carlbom, “Modeling acoustics in virtual environments using the uniform theory of diffraction”, Proceedings of the 28th annual conference on Computer graphics and interactive techniques, pp 545-552, 2001.
T. Funkhouser, N. Tsingos, I. Carlbom, G. Elko, M. Sondhi, J. E West, G. Pingali, P. Min and A. Ngan, “A beam tracing method for interactive architectural acoustics”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 115, pp 739-756, Issue 2, 2003.
R. Ajaj, L. Savioja and C. Jacquemin, “Software platform for real-time room acoustic visualization”, Proceedings of the 2008 ACM symposium on Virtual reality software and technology, pp 247-248, 2008.
S. Laine, S. Siltanen, T. Lokki and L. Savioja, “Accelerated beam tracing algorithm”, Applied Acoustics, Volume 70, Issue 1, pp 172–181, 2009.
F. Antonacci, M. Foco, A. Sarti and S. Tubaro, “Fast Tracing of Acoustic Beams and Paths Through Visibility Lookup”, IEEE Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, Volume 16, Issue 4, pp 812 – 824, 2008.
F. Antonacci, A. Sarti and S. Tubaro, “Two-Dimensional Beam Tracing from Visibility Diagrams for Real-Time Acoustic Rendering”, Proceeded of the 7th Int. Conference on Digital Audio Effects, 2010.
T. Funkhouser, J.-M. Jot and N. Tsingos, “Sounds Good to Me!” Computational Sound for Graphics, Virtual Reality, and Interactive Systems, SIGGRAPH 2002 Course Notes, 2002.
P. Svensson and U.R. Kristiansen, “Computational Modelling and Simulation of Acoustic Spaces”, 22nd International Conference: Virtual, Synthetic, and Entertainment Audio, 2002.
A. Rajkumar, B. F. Naylor, F. Feisullin and L. Rogers, “Predicting RF coverage in large environments using ray-beam tracing and partitioning tree represented geometry”, Wireless Networks, Volume 2, pp 143–154, Issue 2, 1996.
E. Deines, M. Bertram, J. Mohring, J. Jegorovs, F. Michel, H. Hagen and G.M. Nielson, “Comparative Visualization for Wave-based and Geometric Acoustics”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume. 12, pp 1173 – 1180, Issue 5, 2006.
Z. Yamauti, “The light flux distribution of a system of interreflecting surfaces”, J. Opt. Soc. Am., Volume 13, pp 561–571, Issue 5, 1926.
E.M. Nosal, “Room sound field prediction by acoustical radiosity master thesis”, 2002.
J. Shi, A. Zhang, J. Encarnacao and M. Göbel, “A modified radiosity algorithm for integrated visual and auditory rendering”, Computers & Graphics, Volume 17, pp 633-642, Issue 6, 1993.
N. Tsingos and J.D. Gascuel, “A general model for the simulation of room acoustics based on hierarchical radiosity”, SIGGRAPH’97 technical sketch, 1997.
N. Tsingos and J.D. Gascuel, “Acoustic simulation using hierarchical timevarying radiant exchanges”, iMAGIS-GRAVIR/IMAG – Citeseer, 1997.
E.M. Nosal and M. Hodgson, “Preliminary experimental validation of the radiosity technique for predicting room sound fields”, Citeseer.
E.M. Nosal, M. Hodgson and I. Ashdown, “Improved algorithms and methods for room sound-field prediction by acoustical radiosity in arbitrary polyhedral rooms”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 116, pp 970-980, Issue 2, 2004.
J. Kang, Application of radiosity method in acoustic simulation, ICA, 2004.
S. Siltanen, T. Lokki, S. Kiminki and L. Savioja, “The Room Acoustic Rendering Equation”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Volume 122, pp 1624-1635, Issue 3, 2007.
R.T. Muehleisen, “Six Surface Steady State Acoustic Radiosity”, Architectural Engineering Conference (AEI), 2008.
S.M. Pasareanu, “A numerical hybrid method for modeling outdoor sound propagation in complex urban environments”, master thesis, URL: http:// hdl.handle.net/10919/47601, 2014.
M. Sikora, “Algorithms for simulations of sound and ultrasound propagation in complex dispersive environments”, Proceedings Elmar 2004. 46th International Symposium, 2004.
E. Stavrakis, N. Tsingos and P. Calamia, “Topological Sound Propagation with Reverberation Graphs”, Acta Acustica united with Acustica, Volume 94, pp 921-932, Number 6, 2008.
M. Taylor, A. Chandak, L. Antani and D. Manocha, “RESound: Interactive Sound Rendering for Dynamic Virtual Environments”, MM ‘09 Proceedings of the 17th ACM international conference on Multimedia, pp 271-280, 2009.
A. Pohl and U.M. Stephenson, “A Combination of the Sound Particle Simulation Method and the Radiosity Method”, Building Acoustics, Volume 18, pp 97-122, Issue 1/2, 2011.
S. Pelzer, B. Masiero and M. Vorländer, “3D Reproduction of Room Auralizations by Combining Intensity Panning”, Crosstalk Cancellation and Ambisonics, Proc. of the EAA Joint Symposium on Auralization and Ambisonics, Berlin, pp 182-188, 2014.
R. Mehra, A. Rungta, A. Golas, M. Lin and D. Manocha, “WAVE: Interactive Wave-based Sound Propagation for Virtual Environments”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 21, pp 434 – 442, Issue 4, 2015.
P. Charalampous and D. Michael, “Improved hybrid algorithm for real time sound propagation using intelligent prioritization”, Electrotechnical Conference (MELECON), 18th Mediterranean, 2016.
I. Podkosova, M. Urbanek and H. Kaufmann, “A Hybrid Sound Model for 3D Audio Games with Real Walking”, Proceedings of the 29th International Conference on Computer Animation and Social Agents, pp 189-192, 2016.
A. Rungta, C. Schissler, R. Mehra, C. Malloy, M. Lin and D. Manocha, “SynCoPation: Interactive Synthesis-Coupled Sound Propagation”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 22, pp 1346 – 1355, Issue 4, 2016.
B. Smus, “Web Audio API”. O’Reilly Media, Inc, 2013.
R. Spuy, “Sound with the Web Audio API. In Advanced Game Design with HTML5 and JavaScript”. IEEE, 2015.
B. Smus, “Retrieved from Developing Game Audio with the Web Audio API”, Available online: http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/
webaudio/games/ (accessed May 2015).
H. Choi and J. Berger, “WAAX: Web Audio API eXtension”, International Conference on New Interfaces for Musical Expression, KAIST, Daejeon, Korea, 2013
C. Pike, P. Taylour and F. Melchior, “Delivering Object-Based 3D Audio Using The Web Audio API And The Audio Definition Model”, WAC - 1st Web Audio Conference, 2015.
H. Rawlinson, N. Segal and J. Fiala, “Meyda: an audio feature extraction library for the Web Audio API”, WAC - 1st Web Audio Conference, 2015.
J. Kleimola and O. Larkin, “Web Audio Modules”, 12th Sound and Music Computing Conference, Maynooth, Ireland, 2015.
C. Pendharkar, P. Bäck and L. Wyse, “Adventures in scheduling, buffers and parameters: Porting a dynamic audio engine to Web Audio”, WAC - 1st Web Audio Conference, 2015.
N. Schnell, V. Saiz, K. Barkati and S. Goldszmidt, “Of Time Engines and Masters An API for Scheduling and Synchronizing the Generation and Playback of Event Sequences and Media Streams for the Web Audio API”, WAC - 1st Web Audio Conference, 2015.
A. Mahadevan, J. Freeman and B. Magerko, “EarSketch: Teaching computational music remixing in an online Web Audio based learning environment”, WAC - 1st Web Audio Conference, 2015.
A. Stamoulias, E. Lakka and A.G. Malamos, ““Wrapping X3DOM around Web Audio API”, International Journal of Interactive Multimedia and Artificial Intelligence, Volume 3, pp 36-46, Number 5, 2015.
M. Cohen, J. Villegas and W. Barfield, “Special issue on spatial sound in virtual, augmented, and mixed reality environments”, Virtual Reality, Volume 19, pp 147–148, Issue 3, 2015.
Downloads
Published
-
Abstract121
-
PDF38
Submit Article
Information
